Rookie witch / cop Tabitha attempts to prove herself on her first big case, a who-done-it magical multiple homicide. She soon realizes the gravity of the situation when she recognizes one of the victims as a former classmate. In her inexperienced hands, the case becomes a disaster when she inadvertently blows up the crime scene. This leads to her suspension. Undaunted, Tabitha has to work outside the system if she wants show the Order that she is capable of solving the crime.